Legal & Regulation

FBI joins probe into theft of 6,451 PSA-graded cards from FedEx truck

Thieves took two pallets of mostly Pokémon and sports cards on Oct. 13 from a truck parked outside PSA's Santa Ana facility; police put the loss at $963,000.

Business of TCGOct 20, 20261 min read3 sources

Photo: Maxim Tolchinskiy / Unsplash

The FBI has joined the Santa Ana Police Department in investigating the Oct. 13 theft of PSA-graded cards from a FedEx truck parked outside PSA's facility in Santa Ana.

PSA says 6,451 graded cards were stolen, most of them Pokémon and sports cards. The company published a full list of the missing cards and deactivated their certificates.

Among the listed cards are a 1999 first-edition Charizard and a Smaug card from the 2026 Magic: The Gathering set The Hobbit.

Santa Ana police estimated the loss at $963,000. ICv2 said this is likely the insured value submitters declare before grading, so the market value may be higher.

Police said the driver had left the truck for 60 to 90 minutes, during which thieves removed two full pallets and part of a third. No arrests had been made by the time of ICv2's second report.

Collectors Holdings said it had alerted marketplace partners and was arranging compensation for affected customers at fair market value. PSA said it gave investigators video, shipping manifests and records for each item.

Sources

ICv2123 (Oct 20 – Oct 26, 2026)

Related